
DIRECTOR: Dorothy ArznerAlthough not exactly revolutionary in its portrayal of women, Dorothy Arzner's "Dance, Girl, Dance" has some righteous moments for 1940, notably when ballerina Maureen O'Hara dresses down the audience of a burlesque act. Arzner turns the tables on the "male gaze" in another scene, too, with an uncomfortably tight, unrelenting shot of a cigar-chomping nightclub manager who is sizing up the sex appeal of auditioning dancers. At a point in the story ripe for exploitation — half-naked women are writhing, let's watch! — the camera rebels, focusing its impolite stare on the smug and lascivious face of the man whose privilege it is to leer and deliver judgment.
WRITERS: Vicki Baum (story), Frank Davis, Tess Slesinger
PHOTOGRAPHY: Russell Metty
CAST: Maureen O'Hara, Lucille Ball, Louis Hayward, Ralph Bellamy
COUNTRY: USA
GENRE: Drama
MISCELLANY: 90m; bw
The plot mirrors a feminist dilemma, pitting a dancer of dubious talent who cashes in on her ability to pander to male chauvinists against one down to her last dime because she can't play herself cheap. Neither woman is villified. They dance for the same troupe, led by a washed-up Russian ballerina who has traded her tutu for a necktie. Madame Basilova has sold out her ideals to survive, sexing up her dancers and marketing them to various nightclubs. The troupe is hard to sell, though, without their vampy leader, Bubbles, played by Lucille Ball. Even the gorgeous Judy, played by a young but ever-feisty Maureen O'Hara, can't cut it. The girl can dance, but it does her little good because she lacks what Madame Basilova terms "oomph," a trait she describes as a birthright and which Bubbles has in spades.
Watching Ball before she was Lucy, well after she became Lucy and an icon of women's liberation, makes it difficult to imagine how she struck audiences in 1940. The TV Lucy we love is a married housewife, not an exotic dancer, but she is a lot like Bubbles, full of Ball's trademark sarcasm, and delightfully unafraid of appearing unladylike. This must have been a revelation at the time, but I take it for granted in 2010.
O'Hara's Judy is an aspiring ballerina with raw talent, fated by financial necessity to play Bubbles' stooge in a burlesque act that contrasts the proverbial good girl against the bad girl. Guess who the audience favors? Still, everyone except Bubbles admits the act is nothing without Judy to absorb the audience's abuse. The act parallels the competition between the dancers for the attention of Jimmy, a millionaire with an alcohol problem who likes Judy because she reminds him of his ex-wife Elinor but doesn't offer much resistance when Bubbles tries to turn his head.
The film avoids cliches, and aside from Judy, no character is wholly good or bad, and relationships, like Jimmy and Elinor's, are not clearly defined.


